There are unlimited ways to make a tooth fairy pillow, but I thought I would share one easy way with you.
4″ Square for front center – this could be a cross stitch piece, a quilt square, a fancy fabric (The Lightning Bug pattern I used is a design by San-Man Originals)
Fabric to frame the front square – 2 pieces 1 1/2″ by 4″ and 2 pieces 1 1/2″ by 6 1/2″
6 1/2″ square of fabric for back
Contrasting or complimentary fabric for the tooth pocket 3″ square
Something to use as a hang (ribbon, twine, embroidery floss) about 8″ long